Webinar | Winning Preference Across the Buying Group:
From Strategy to First Steps
Catch the replay of our webinar featuring guest speaker Kelvin Gee, Principal Analyst, Forrester, with Lynn Tornabene, Chief Marketing and Product Officer, Anteriad.
Most buyers walk in with a favorite, so marketers need to build preference early and strengthen it across everyone who has to agree on the purchase.
What you'll take away:
Ready to become the frontrunner?
Go deeper with these resources:
Forrester Blog
Go deeper on why Preference Marketing matters and how brand and demand teams can work together to build it.
Building Preference Is The Key To Winning B2B BuyersForrester blog by Ian Bruce and Kelvin Gee, Forrester
Learn why buyers pick a frontrunner early, and how shared metrics and preference signals help brand and demand teams compete for that spot.
Read More Don’t Be Late to the Party: A Data-First Strategy for Marketing to Buying GroupsAnteriad eBook
A practical guide to reaching the whole buying group, not just the one contact who filled out a form.
Read MoreMeet the speakers
Lynn Tornabene Chief Marketing and Product Officer, Anteriad
Kelvin Gee Principal Analyst, Forrester
Bring the conversation back to your team
Building preference across a buying group takes more than one person. Share these resources with the colleagues who need to be part of the decision, and start the conversation about your first pilot.
We’re here to help.
Anteriad presented a webinar featuring Kelvin Gee, Principal Analyst, Forrester
Winning Preference Across the Buying Group: From Strategy to First Steps
Transcript
Welcome and introductions (0:42)
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: While everybody is joining, I want to welcome you and say thank you for spending part of your afternoon with us. I'm Dee Blohm, and I lead marketing and communications here at Anteriad. We're glad you were able to join us for today's session, Winning Preference Across the Buying Group: From Strategy to First Steps.
I'd love to introduce our speakers. Our guest speaker is Kelvin Gee, Principal Analyst at Forrester. Kelvin brings over 20 years of demand marketing experience, from high-tech firms and startups to larger enterprises. Prior to joining Forrester, Kelvin spent time at Oracle, where he led account-based marketing and the Center of Excellence.
He's joined by Lynn Tornabene, Chief Marketing and Product Officer at Anteriad. Before joining Anteriad, Lynn held roles at Apple, Google, DoubleClick, Wunderman and IBM. She and Kelvin also worked together at Oracle, where she was Global VP in the Advertising and Marketing Solutions division. Thank you both for bringing your expertise to today's session. Welcome.
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Thank you. Happy to be here.
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: Thank you.
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: Before we get started, a quick pit stop for some housekeeping. We'll spend about 45 minutes on the content, and then we'll open it up for questions. You can drop questions into the Q&A box. If you click More at the bottom, you should see the Q&A. We'll get to as many questions as we can at the end of the program.
The session will be recorded, so you don't need to spend today taking notes. You'll get a copy of the replay tomorrow by email.
So, why the race theme? Our featured speaker, Kelvin, is going to show you why a lot of races are decided before the green flag ever drops. Kelvin, over to you.
The McLaren story: fixing the whole system (2:42)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Great, thank you, Dee. As you can see, I'm going to be talking about winning preference across the buying group, from strategy to first steps. Again, I'm Kelvin Gee, Principal Analyst at Forrester. My research coverage includes marketing programs and ABM. I evaluate revenue marketing platforms, and I talk a lot about Preference Marketing.
But before I get into it, I want to talk about something else. Surprisingly, this something else is related to B2B marketing, and that, of course, is Formula One racing.
Imagine that you're a team principal for a Formula One team, and you're entering a race knowing full well you've got no chance of winning it at all. That's a very uncomfortable and unsettling feeling. But that is exactly what Team McLaren felt at the beginning of their 2023 season, when things just weren't working right.
Team McLaren is not an inexperienced team. They are one of the most well-known, strongest brands in all of motorsports. They have a very talented team of drivers, a very strong engineering team with great racing technology, and lots and lots of data. And it's not like they weren't working hard. They were. But for whatever reason, they just weren't gelling, and it wasn't delivering results. They were basically at the bottom of the Formula One rankings in 2023.
In Formula One, you might think the normal thing to do is just juice the engine and add more power. But that doesn't always guarantee more speed, because if you optimize one component in isolation, the whole car can still get slower. You might add more engine power, and that might add more speed, but it also introduces more heat, more fuel consumption and reliability issues. You might play with the aerodynamics and increase downforce. That might add more grip, but it also introduces more drag and wears down your tires faster. You might add more people. That might increase effort, but it might also introduce more alignment issues.
The issue wasn't just one thing. It wasn't a lack of engineering, or team, or effort. It was a system-level performance issue.
So Andrea Stella, the new team principal at McLaren, had to hit the reset button. He had to change the culture of finger-pointing and reframe the question from "Who failed? Who's at fault?" to "What is preventing the system from working?" He had to coordinate all the teams to align around one question and one goal: How do we deliver better results? How do we win the race? To do that, you have to coordinate engineering, the strategy team and the data team, and incorporate driver insight into the car for upgrades. In other words, they had to create a closed-loop system of self-improvement to optimize performance.
It wasn't until the Austrian Grand Prix later that year that they placed fourth. Fourth place doesn't put you on the podium, so you might be asking, what's the big deal? But compared to where they were earlier in the season, this was an unheard-of result. Slowly, they incorporated more feedback, more upgrades followed, and then more podium finishes happened.
Again, it wasn't a single breakthrough. It was a faster closed-loop learning process. And less than two seasons later, in 2024, they won the Constructors' Championship, their first since 1998. It wasn't a one-off, either. They repeated as champions in 2025.
The same drivers didn't suddenly become more talented. The team didn't discover more effort. The organization didn't simply collect more data. Instead, McLaren aligned the parts around one outcome: making the entire car faster.
Three ways to improve go-to-market performance (8:10)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Which brings us to our topic, B2B marketing. B2B marketing is also a team sport, but it's often disguised as a technology problem. Again, it's not typically just one thing. You have different components. You have the brand team, the demand team, sales, your platforms and content. So if things aren't going right, the fix is typically not just one thing. It's not just improving the engine. It's optimizing the entire ecosystem for a better race operation.
We're going to talk about three things you can do to optimize and improve your go-to-market performance. Number one is the strategy, specifically Preference Marketing. Number two is the operating model: the roles, the teams, the workflows. And number three is how to scale by using agentic marketing and making the move to buying groups.
Buyers start with a frontrunner in mind (9:19)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: So let's get started and talk about the strategy.
Formula One is one of the most exacting and technically competitive sports in the world today. Teams invest hundreds of millions of dollars designing, testing and preparing their cars and drivers to win on race day. But here's the thing. Every F1 team knows the race doesn't really start on race day. It begins the day before, in qualifying, when they fight to earn pole position so they can line up as the lead car on race day. When you post the fastest qualifying lap and secure pole position, your odds of winning the race jump dramatically. On average, 40% to 50% of all F1 races are won from pole position. That's why qualifying is the real competition.
In B2B, buyers don't start with an even grid either. We might imagine that they do, but that's just wishful thinking. In reality, at the start of the buyer's journey, at the start of the race if you will, buyers have clear vendor preferences in mind. They've already decided which vendors are in pole position, which ones are at the back of the grid, and which vendors don't even qualify for the race at all.
When we look at the buyer's journey, the data is very clear. In our research, the Forrester Buyers' Journey Survey, which is a very large survey of over 12,000 responses, 68% of B2B buyers reported that they have a preferred vendor at the start of the formal purchasing process. And of that 68%, 80% of these buyers select that preferred vendor.
So buyers know which vendors they want to work with long before the buyer's journey begins. In fact, more than half the time, the race is already won. When you do the math, the preferred vendor wins around 55% of the time. Those are better odds than the pole position numbers I cited earlier. And let's be honest, I'm willing to bet every attendee in this webinar would take those odds every single day.
So here's the harsh truth. Stop chasing deals you've already lost, because most of the time, they have been lost if you haven't done the hard work of earning buyer preference earlier on. The buyer's journey has become a process of confirmation, not selection.
AI-assisted discovery and the buying network (12:49)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: So we've established that buyers develop preferences earlier in the process, and that you have to earn preference earlier. There are two other market shifts you need to be aware of.
One is AI-assisted discovery. AI changes how buyers find information and compare alternatives, earlier and earlier. They're not using Google Search anymore. They're using their answer engine of choice to start, narrow down and figure out who's on that shortlist.
And we've known for a long time that it's not one single individual making an enterprise decision by him or herself. It's a buying group, a collective effort. They seek evidence and trusted voices to reduce risk. According to our research, the average enterprise buying group is around 17 people. And of those 17 people, about half aren't even on the payroll of your target accounts. These are outside influencers, and we refer to this as the buying network: agencies, consultants, analysts like myself, peers, customers and influencers. You have to win over their hearts and minds earlier and earlier in the process.
So, collectively, across all three market shifts, the growth opportunity starts before demand becomes visible. Your job as a marketer is to get into pole position. The question is, how do you do that? You get there by earning buyer preference. The data I showed you makes clear that you need to win over the hearts and minds of B2B buyers before they start the formal purchase process and before they signal intent. Earning buyer preference is what gets you into pole position and gives you the best odds of winning the race and winning the business.
So clearly, the job of marketing must change.
Uniting brand and demand with Preference Marketing (15:08)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: But here's the problem. B2B marketing is not set up or optimized to earn buyer preference today. Today, B2B marketing is a house divided. Marketing teams are in a bit of a hot mess. They're not organized, structured or run in ways that help them build buyer preference. In fact, the reverse is true.
On the left, you've got Team Brand, represented by Ian Bruce, my colleague here at Forrester who covers brand marketing. And then there's Team Demand on the right, represented by yours truly, with 20-plus years doing demand gen in B2B.
These are two separate organizations, with separate programs and separate budgets, competing for the same resources. We're also using disconnected metrics that are often unaligned with buyer needs. It's almost as if we're driving two competing cars in the same race, even though we're supposed to be on the same team. This is untenable, and it's not what modern B2B buyers want.
So the question is, how do we get into pole position? You get there by uniting brand and demand with Preference Marketing in mind. Preference Marketing is the engine of integrated brand and demand teams. A focus on building preference gives you a unified, shared approach that connects brand building to demand performance. It coordinates campaigns and shared budgets. It's a way to directly connect brand investments to business outcomes, and it's a driver for demand programs that deliver long-term growth. But most important of all, it aligns with buyer needs.
So you might be asking, what is Preference Marketing? Preference Marketing prioritizes building early affinity and long-term loyalty among ever more decisive buyers, requiring brand and demand marketing to unite to drive impact.
The operating model and measuring preference (17:36)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Now that we've established that Preference Marketing is the North Star and the right strategy, let's shift and talk about the operating model: the roles, the teams and the workflows.
First, let's talk about how to integrate brand and demand. It starts with unified planning and messaging. It requires your brand team to open up [edited] and share with the demand team what they're working on and planning. Do they have a reputation or brand program in the works? Same thing with the demand team. They have to open up and share what they're doing. So it may make sense to start planning these things together, or better yet, build a whole unified program from the ground up.
Next, through this work of unified planning, you might realize you have to redesign your content. Redesign the look and feel, make sure your assets have a family resemblance, or close gaps in your content strategy where you don't have the right content. You need this content to drive thought leadership and early influence.
Next, you might need to integrate your campaigns and execute across teams. Maybe your brand program shouldn't run one quarter and your demand program the next. Maybe they need to run and execute together. And maybe you need to connect them so your brand program drives to actual demand offers, demand landing pages, microsites or your other digital properties. Ultimately, you're building a culture of long-term brand and demand collaboration, which is a muscle most organizations haven't exercised yet.
Once you do that, you can start to align other teams, like operations and sales, around preference creation, which again is the established North Star. And finally, you want to update your metrics and KPIs to reflect these fused goals, because you don't want to just measure fluffy brand metrics like awareness.
Speaking of measurement, Formula One is a great case study. In Formula One, teams don't rely on gut feel. They measure everything. They build complex telemetry dashboards that track shift patterns, brake pressure, gear selection, aerodynamics, tire temperature, tire wear. The list goes on and on. And they do it in real time, or close to real time, to achieve the fastest possible lap.
In B2B marketing, we need to build our own telemetry dashboard as well. It starts with understanding how buyers build their shortlist and how they build preference. A helpful model is the Forrester brand measurement framework, which you see here.
Starting from the bottom, you first need to build awareness. It might come from the Department of Duh, but people can't buy from you if they don't know who you are. But that's not enough. People also need to understand your perception and the category you belong in. Does Tesla sell cars, or does it sell refrigerators? Buyers need to understand which category you're in and which business and market segments you serve. But that's not enough either. What about sentiment? Is it positive or negative? They might know who you are and which category you're in, but they might hate you, or your attitudes and values might be different from what they believe in. So you need to establish all three, awareness, perception and sentiment, and all three inform and drive preference.
And then, lastly, loyalty and advocacy come post-purchase. When prospects become customers and have hands on keyboards using your products and services, that forms preferences, and they can start telling friends and family how great you are.
Here's a real-world example. I talked about the buying network earlier and how you have to influence it before the formal purchase process starts. This is a client that did exactly that. They defined their buying network, both the internal buying group and the external influencers, and they were doing quite well, with the exception of analysts. For some reason, the analyst community did not like them. They knew they had a gap there, so they invested in an analyst program to change that perception and win over the analyst community. This is an example of how you can measure preference across your buying network, understand your gaps and invest in programs to close them.
Now let's talk about how you can build your preference telemetry. We just covered how to measure preference using the Forrester brand measurement framework, but you also need to measure buying group interactions. A practical way to do this is to compare first-party and third-party signals.
For example, if you have early, strong and persistent first-party and third-party interactions across the buying group, then congratulations, the news is good. Preference is probably strong, and buyers are probably thinking of you first. You might even be on the shortlist, and heck, you might even be in pole position.
But the inverse is also possible. If first-party engagement is weaker and less consistent than third-party signals, the news is not so good. That probably means buyers are in market, but they're not considering you, let alone preferring you. That's why you need to triangulate and measure first-party and third-party signals together.
And finally, you want to connect these signals to downstream outcomes, like conversion rates, sales velocity and win rates, to show your board and management team that preference is working, and that you're not just measuring fluffy things like awareness that the board doesn't really care about.
This quote from Paulo Provincale [verify spelling] from LinkedIn says it all: "You don't have to guess at preference. You can see it in surveys. In sales conversations. In lead quality. In sales velocity. The signals are there if you're willing to look beyond click-through rate."
The Preference Marketing Matrix (25:21)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Next, let's talk about how to calibrate your brand and demand investments based on how much buyers favor you. Here I'm showing the Forrester Preference Marketing Matrix, a simple, easy-to-understand 2x2 model.
Along the y-axis, you have market preference for a given market. This is the analysis we discussed earlier with the brand measurement framework pyramid. Along the x-axis are buying group interactions, the triangulation of first-party and third-party interactions we just discussed. Taken together, these insights help you understand your preference positioning and how to engage based on how much buyers favor you.
If market preference and interaction are both high, congratulations, you're in pole position. With this advantage, you should defend your position against competitors while validating your value proposition. That means you might invest in analyst reports that validate your leadership position, strong case studies and ROI calculators. You might even expand the size of your opportunity, because why not? You're in the leadership position. Apple is an example of a company in pole position in the North American smartphone market.
What if market preference is strong, but buyer interaction is low? Then you're a contender. Here, the priority is to convert market preference into active pipeline. You also want to deepen engagement with demand programs and build and expand the buying group we talked about. Samsung is an example of a contender in the smartphone market.
What if the overall market doesn't see you as a leader or first choice yet, but buyers are still interacting with you? Then you're an underdog. Here, you want to maintain demand momentum while investing in brand programs to increase trust, credibility and authority. Google is an example of an underdog.
And lastly, if the market doesn't prefer you and buyers aren't interacting with you, then unfortunately, you're a long shot. Here, you might need to test and validate your ideal customer profile and fit. Run a pilot, and don't overinvest. If things still aren't viable, you might have to cut your losses and exit the market altogether. Motorola might be an example of a long shot in the smartphone market.
So once you understand the 2x2 and where you land relative to your competitors, you can design playbooks to move you into the right quadrant.
Scaling with AI and agents (28:57)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Finally, let's talk about scale, and how to use agentic marketing and buying groups to build on what you're already doing.
We've established that preference sets the purpose: earning the buyer's trust and choice earlier in the process. Agents and AI can help put that into practice. They can help coordinate and build relevant experiences based on buyer needs, as those needs change.
If we look at where our jobs were and where the market's headed, the marketer's job is becoming more and more about orchestration. We're basically the conductor of an orchestra now.
Look back at the campaigns of yesterday. It used to be a limited set of planned campaign launches or product launches. Now it's about connecting buyer interactions in real time, or close to real time, with an always-on mentality, and tracking the different stages of the buyer's journey. So instead of three or four big campaigns, you're looking at an always-on construct. Instead of a fixed audience segment, you're looking at dynamic segments that change with different signals. You have to adapt to different buyers and the different roles in that buying group.
Before, you focused on specific channels, and some organizations are organized by channel. Now you have to think multichannel: delivering the same consistent message across different channels to the same buyer, adapted to the different stages of the buyer's journey.
And then finally, reporting. Typically, we report after the campaign runs. Now, with real-time signals and data, we can track and course correct before the campaign ends. We can see whether a tactic, asset or channel is underperforming, and replace it with better-performing channels or assets. We don't have to wait until six months later to find out something underperformed, because by then it's too late.
A helpful model is the Forrester Adaptive Program Execution Framework, which you see here. There are three circles, three phases, and AI is at the center of all three. Surrounding all three phases are these Möbius strips, which are the signals you have access to.
The first phase is the define phase. This is audience definition, where you target and segment your audience. You can do that at the account level. That's account-based marketing, using things like fit models and intent to define which accounts are more likely to buy. More mature marketers are moving toward buying groups, which we'll talk about in a minute: understanding buying group coverage, buying group roles, how they interact and which buying groups are more likely to convert. If you're still on the lowly MQL treadmill, that's fine. A lot of organizations are. But you can still use data and AI to help predict which leads are going to convert. So that's the audience definition phase.
The second phase is how you deliver a multichannel, consistent and personalized buying experience. There are three elements to this. The first is the delivery mechanism, or channel: understanding channel preferences based on your buyers' signals. Some people are more inclined to go to YouTube versus Reddit. Some people are on LinkedIn. So understand where the fish are swimming, and go there. Next, there's asset type. Some people prefer longer content, like the 30-page eBook. Some people prefer the shorter two-minute video [edited]. So understand the asset types your buyers prefer, and personalize to them. And then there's the theme: treating your content as a modular asset and personalizing it based on each role in the buying group. Financial decision-makers and influencers need different content and different messages than technical decision-makers. So understand the roles, and deliver the personalized content they need to make those decisions.
And lastly, the optimize phase. We're marketers, so of course we're going to measure everything under the sun. But how do we distill and synthesize all this data into meaningful insights, so we can determine the next best action? Is this opportunity sales-ready for a conversation? And if it isn't, maybe the next best experience is to put them into a different long-term program, for example.
So this is a helpful framework for thinking about how AI and agents can help you execute across all three phases.
From MQLs to buying groups (35:01)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Speaking of buyers and buying groups, for years we thought our buyer was the lowly MQL, and unfortunately, our systems and processes have been built around it.
In reality, we've realized that the lead-centric demand process is not working. Most of our clients see a very low conversion rate from marketing qualified lead to sales qualified opportunity, typically 1% or less. We also typically see one contact, and sometimes technically half a contact, associated with each opportunity.
In reality, buyers look more like the right-hand side of the slide. Buyers make decisions in groups, in buying groups. In fact, our data shows that 70% of B2B buying decisions involve three or more departments, and that number jumps to 90% when you count two or more departments. And these buyers have different roles. They're champions, decision-makers, influencers, users and ratifiers.
Once you understand this, and that each of them has their own selfish needs, you can start to take advantage of it. A champion is going to focus on business value. A ratifier is going to be concerned about total cost of ownership and understanding the alternatives. The influencer is going to worry about performance. Is it stable? Is it reliable? Is it efficient? A CXO decision-maker is going to be concerned about ROI and business value. And the user is going to care about whether your solution will help her do her job better.
Think of it as a series of Russian dolls you have to connect. The largest doll is the market segment you serve. The next smaller doll is the account. Underneath that is the buying group, and that's the sweet spot: understanding the collection of personas involved in the purchase process and catering to them as a unit. And then the atomic level is the persona, the individuals who form the buying group, and messaging each member based on their role.
When you make this shift to buying groups, many of our clients have seen a massive shift in efficiency and scale. Because at the end of the day, what do sales teams want more than one conversation? Multiple conversations. That's what you're doing when you move to buying groups. You're delivering multiple contacts to sales, which is ultimately what they'll need to close the deal anyway. So why delay the obvious? Be proactive and deliver those buying group members in advance, identifying them and personalizing your message to them. You start to see a big shift in efficiency and scale. You're serving up six-packs of beer to sales instead of single cans, and that's ultimately what they want.
Kelvin's three calls to action (38:52)
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: As I wrap up, three main calls to action to get into pole position.
First, build preference. Define your narrative and your unique point of view, assemble proof points like analyst reports and case studies, and activate them across your top channels.
Next, measure preference. Build that telemetry dashboard, like Formula One. Stand up a preference telemetry dashboard with sales, marketing and customer marketing, and review it weekly. Try to do this in the next 30, 60 or 90 days.
And lastly, deploy playbooks. Operationalize a repeatable playbook based on where you sit in the 2x2 matrix, with clear goals, tactics, channels and metrics. Build it as a closed-loop system so you're learning as you go, like Team McLaren did in the story I told earlier.
And with that, I'll pass it to Lynn to talk about buying groups.
Does a buying group approach pay off? (40:05)
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: Well, thank you, Kelvin, for that very insightful presentation, and for provoking our audience to think about where they should go next. You showed us that more than half the time, the race is decided before it starts, and that buying groups are really where that preference is won.
So now I want to take the strategy you laid out and bring it down to some first steps for implementing buying groups. I'm going to share what over 600 marketers globally told us in our B2B Marketing Edge research, and then recommend how you can begin.
The question we often hear from marketers is pretty simple: Does it pay off? It's hard. Moving to buying groups can feel like a big risk.
In our survey, we compared teams that fully implemented buying groups with teams that only use them in a limited way. Fully implemented means defined, activated and central to how they go to market, across preference and demand. Those teams that fully implemented were five times as likely to have grown revenue significantly in the past year, and more than three times as likely to have significantly exceeded their marketing goals. I'd be very happy to see those numbers, and I imagine most of the audience would be too.
What stands in the way (41:52)
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: So if it does pay off, why isn't everyone doing this? Kelvin, you and others have been telling us for years to shift to buying groups because they better reflect how buyers make decisions.
Here's what your peers, marketers around the world, told us stands in the way. There's the complexity of implementation. This is hard to do. There's not knowing who is in the buying group, so where do I even start? 37% said that. There was concern about having the right content for the different roles, which you talked about. And almost a third said there's internal resistance to moving away from MQLs.
Most of these are very practical problems. They're not doubts that buying groups are the right thing to do, and that's good news, because problems like that can be fixed. So if you're still measured on MQLs and you have those barriers, let's spend a few minutes on how you can get started.
First steps: pilot, evidence, internal support (42:53)
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: Kelvin, you gave us the moves that get you into pole position. Now let's take our first laps: three things you can start tomorrow. A pilot, gathering evidence and building support.
First, start small. In Kelvin's terms, this is your first playbook. Pick a few accounts and map who is in each buying group. You can use the content you already have to make sure the whole buying group gets one shared story, because they're going to make that decision together. Map that existing content to the questions each person is asking based on their role in the decision.
Then fuel that pilot with quality data. Layer buying group intelligence with intent and contact data directly into your current workflows. You don't need a new platform to do this, though you probably will need better insights and data than you have today.
And start where you are. Even among the marketers who fully implemented buying groups, 31% still named MQLs as their top success measure. So you can begin without throwing out what you're measured on today.
Second, track results on your pilot accounts, so you have evidence beyond a good story. This is the start of the preference telemetry Kelvin just described. Here are the gains full implementers reported most. Six in 10 saw better marketing and sales alignment. Almost the same number said they saw higher win rates. More than half saw better conversion from opportunity to closed revenue. These are the measures you'll want on your pilot scorecard. Win rates and conversion show up in revenue, and that's the kind of evidence your sales and finance partners want when you're trying to change how you go to market.
And finally, you need to build internal support, particularly with your CFO. Kelvin talked about tying preference to the metrics your leadership cares about, and your CFO often owns those metrics or has a big say in how they're set.
Here's why that matters. When marketing and the CFO aren't on the same page, about 4 in 10 of your peers said they faced more scrutiny on their spend, 36% saw their budgets cut, and 35% saw big initiatives delayed. Buying groups and Preference Marketing are exactly the kind of initiatives that may get delayed without that alignment. So bring your CFO or finance partner in early, when you're designing the pilot. Agree on what success looks like and when you'll measure it, and then let those results make the case for you.
To recap: pilot a buying group approach, gather the evidence and build internal support, because buying groups really do pay off. The barriers are real, but they're manageable. You can start small, often with content and tools you already have, and that's how you move up the grid.
Now I'll pass it over to Dee for some Q&A, so we can answer your questions, and then we'll wrap up.
Q&A: Getting on the shortlist when buyers research with AI (46:19)
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: Thank you both. I really appreciate Kelvin's Formula One references, and I did count how many times you said awareness was fluffy. That'll be another conversation.
We do have some questions. The first one is for Kelvin. Buyers are using AI tools for more of their early research. How does a seller earn a spot on the shortlist before the buyer ever talks to a vendor?
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: It's a good question, and a common one, because the process has changed, as we all know. It's basically forced marketers to start investing in answer engine optimization, or AEO. That means looking at their content and how it's structured on the website, and moving away from fluffy, generic content to content that's very prescriptive and builds trust, credibility and authority, structured in a way answer engines can scrape.
But that's not all. You need to build content across your community and your buying network. Have influencers talk about you on Reddit, on LinkedIn, wherever your buyers are. Again, fish where the fish are swimming. Understand your channels and where your buyers reside, and have your influencers and customers comment there too. Advocacy becomes a big part of it. Are customers singing your praises? Are they advocates or detractors?
Those are things marketing needs to work on. Answer engines are either going to mention your brand in their results, or they're not. That's the first layer of the pyramid I talked about, awareness. Number one, are they mentioning you? Check or uncheck. But then, what about perception? Are they mentioning you in the right category? Maybe it's not the category or market you want to be in. Or if you're moving into a new market, maybe they're still mentioning you in your old one. So make sure answer engines have the right perception of which category and market you serve. And then, again, the sentiment. Are they saying good things or bad things about you?
That's all based on the information out on the web: customer reviews, analyst reports, peer reviews and so on. Those inform the answer engines. So you have to do your homework and build the content and messages that will help influence them.
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: Lynn, do you want to add anything there?
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: I think Kelvin covered that extensively, so nothing to add on that one. Thank you, Kelvin.
Q&A: Choosing pilot accounts and buying group roles (49:46)
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: This one's for Lynn. You said to start with a few accounts. How do you choose which ones, and how many people in each buying group should you try to reach?
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: That's a great question. First, pick accounts that look like your best customers and are already showing signs of intent that they're in market. That gives your pilot its best shot at showing results quickly.
On how many people, I'd think about the roles more than the headcount. As Kelvin walked through, you have your champion, your decision-maker, your influencers, your users and your ratifiers. Try to reach somebody in each of those roles, and there may be multiple people in each role at the company.
And make sure you keep that list fresh. One thing we've seen in our data is that buying groups change as a deal moves along. Particularly in deals that take 8, 12 or 18 months to close, the roles may change, and so may who's in them. So you have to keep that data fresh, and the teams we see do well update who's in the group over time.
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: I'll second that. Again, our research shows there are about 17 members in an enterprise-sized buying group, on average. You don't have to activate and message every individual member. It's the decision-makers and key influencers, so identify the right roles in the buying group.
And as Lynn said, you typically have a foothold with maybe one persona. Most clients need to expand that buying group, fill in the gaps and identify the right members. Maybe you have an end user but not the decision-maker. Maybe you've got the procurement team but not the financial decision-maker. So understand your gaps, then build programs that help you identify the right people and engage them.
Q&A: What to measure alongside MQLs (52:06)
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: I have a question I'm going to hand over to you, Kelvin, from someone on the lowly MQL treadmill. "My team is still measured on MQLs. If preference forms before a buyer ever fills out a form, what should we measure instead, or alongside it?"
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Good question. Going back to that 2x2 grid, you need to measure preference across two dimensions. Preference isn't a yes or no. You have to measure market preference, using things like brand measurement studies to see how your brand is perceived in a particular market. And then look at how buyers are engaging with you.
Once you can do that, you can build a modular score internally, much like what you do today with lead scores or buying group scores. You can build a preference score by triangulating your data, normalizing it and standardizing it. It could be a numeric score from 0 to 100, for example. Then deliver that to your business development reps (BDRs). It will inform their conversations, because they'll know whether you're in pole position or not. And if you're not in pole position, they'll know how to tailor the conversation.
Wrap-up (53:43)
Dee Blohm, Anteriad: Thank you, I appreciate that. We're coming up on time, so that's all the time we have for questions. I think we got to everything in the Q&A.
We've got a QR code here for some useful assets from Forrester and Anteriad. You don't have to worry about scanning it right now, because I'll be sending an email after the event, likely tomorrow. It will include the recording, the blog posts Kelvin mentioned and a long-form eBook on the buying group. All of these are great resources to help you start building preference across the buying group.
I'd like to thank both of our presenters for joining us today. Lynn and Kelvin, you brought a great conversation. And thank you to everybody who joined us and spent part of your day with us. We'll see you next time. Have a great rest of your day.
Kelvin Gee, Forrester: Thanks, everyone.
Lynn Tornabene, Anteriad: Thank you.